Testing for Intelligence

The holistic approach (the whole child)  is focused on developing all areas of a child which are viewed as interrelated (Smidt, 2006 p. 2). The view of this perspective is that one domain does not exist without the assistance of another. These interrelated domains include social/emotional (psychosocial), physical (biosocial) and the cognitive domains.

With the holistic approach in mind, I believe that children should be evaluated, but only minimally during the early childhood years because it can be inappropriate for this developmental stage.  When a child reaches the middle childhood years, children seem to be assessed more. I feel that the assessing at this stage can be quite excessive and strenuous for the children as well.

As a result, I would assess children during the early childhood years to determine if they are demonstrating a set of key developmental indicators during their play based experiences like with the High scope curriculum used in my Early Head Start classroom for infants through preschool aged children.

However, I would assess children within the middle childhood years through a performance based assessment which would show what they know to determine what skills they have mastered for various subjects. I believe that sometimes children are unable to express their knowledge through formalized testing methods, but when they are allowed to demonstrate their knowledge through performance, this method seems to be more effective for children. For instance, when a child can show you an AB pattern using colored blocks in Kindergarten, this would allow them to apply the knowledge they have learned. In addition, another example would be when an older student reads a book to his teacher so she can determine what reading level the child has reached. These strategies would be more effective in demonstrating what a child has learned versus the conventional testing procedures currently used.

 I was curious about how other parts of the world assess children. So, I chose the country of China because I always have viewed the children in this country as very smart. I have observed how some parents are very adamant about their children being academically successful which I feel is not totally negative. As a result, they encourage their children to become white-collar professionals, typically doctors, engineers or attorneys.  As a result, I wondered how this country would assess its school aged children. The China’s National Children Center and Professor Tori Linder has begun to implement a play based assessment in one of the Kindergarten classrooms in Beijing, China. In this assessment, teachers would observe their students in a more natural environment to learn about their development based on their interactions through play experiences very similiar to the US. Implementing this different approach to teaching in China has been met with a challenge because it is not the traditional view of teaching. However, Professor Linder is determined to change the traditional views of teaching in China to help teachers evaluate their students with more developmentally appropriate assessments.

Smidt, S. (2006). The developing child in the 21^st century: a global perspective on child development.

New York, NY: Routledge

CRIEnglish.com. (2008). Assess children through plays: A New Approach Introduced to China. Retrieved

from: http://english.cri.cn/4026/2008/05/30/167@363568.htm.